‘Thumbs of our artisans were cut off by invaders’: PM Modi recalls the dark chapter of the country’s history in Lucknow; read how Indian weavers were brutalised by the colonisers
· OpIndia
On 21st November (Saturday), Prime Minister Narendra Modi attended the fifth Kaushal Deekshant Samaroh (National Skill Convocation Ceremony) in Lucknow. While addressing the audience, he recalled India’s glorious past in craftsmanship and manufacturing, and the brutal fate it met at the hands of invaders.
Visit casino-promo.biz for more information.
PM Modi stated, “Friends, in the destruction of India’s skill system, another factor was also to blame. When invaders came to our country, our country – carrying a golden era – was for the world a centre of attraction as well as a centre of envy. And when they came to India, what did they do? Their very first blow was struck at craft. Many of you children as well must have read in history – our artisans who used to exist; if someone made something and that thing turned out to be the best, then the thumbs of the one who made it would be cut off. Why? Those aggressors knew that it was craft; it was the skill in their hands that was making India great and prosperous.”
He further conveyed, “They wanted to destroy this strength and, to achieve this, they cut off the thumbs of craftsmen. Later, the British arrived, and they adopted a sophisticated approach. They introduced an education system that reduced the skills of Indian craftsmen to clerical work under Macaulay’s framework.”
Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh: At the Kaushal Deekshant Samaroh, PM Narendra Modi says, "Friends, in the destruction of India’s skill system, another factor was also to blame. When invaders came to our country, our country—carrying a golden era—was for the world a center of attraction as well as a center of envy. And when they came to India, what did they do? Their very first blow was struck at craft. Many of you children as well must have read in history—our artisans who used to exist, if someone made something and that thing turned out to be the best, then the thumbs of the one who made it would be cut off. Why? Those aggressors knew that it is craft, it is the skill in their hands, that was making India great and prosperous…" (Source: PM Narendra Modi YT)
— IANS (@ians_india) November 21, 2026
The historical background to PM Modi’s statement
PM Modi’s statement is rooted in the dark history of the treatment meted out to Indian craftsmen at the hands of foreign colonisers. There is a notorious legend about Mughal emperor Shah Jahan related to chopping off the hands of the Taj Mahal’s builders so that nobody could ever build another one.
According to the legend, Shah Jahan was so impressed with the Taj Mahal that he ordered the craftsmen’s hands to be severed, making it impossible for such a monument to ever be constructed again. It is also said that he gouged out their eyes so they would never see something more exquisite than the monument.
However, the oldest written account of thumbs being cut in Bengal is in “Considerations on India Affairs,” published in 1772 by William Bolts, a Dutch-born merchant who had worked for the East India Company in Bengal before falling out with it. He described the treatment of Bengal’s weavers by the Company’s agents, including their capture, imprisonment, confinement in iron, fines, and flogging.
Bolt shared the disturbing experience in his writings, which disclosed, “In the provision of the Honourable Company’s investment, the rigorous and oppressive measures taken with the manufacturers, in some places, have occasioned nagaads, or winders of raw silk, to cut off their thumbs, to prevent their being forced to work; though it is better since an increase of pay took place.”
Notably, 80 years later Karl Marx described the destruction of Indian weaving in his famous one-liner, which read, “It was the British intruder who broke up the Indian hand-loom and destroyed the spinning-wheel.” It was featured in his 1853 article “The British Rule in India,” written for the “New-York Daily Tribune.”
The harrowing account was also recounted by Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi in 1921 when he mentioned, “During the East India Company regime, spinning or weaving had become almost a crime. The labour of these artisans was so cruelly suppressed that they were obliged to cut off their own thumbs in order to avoid imprisonment,” in his note titled “Who cut the thumbs” in Young India.
In the same note, he recorded that many speakers of the day were saying that the Company’s servants themselves had cut off the artisans’ thumbs and added that, in his opinion, such cutting off “would be less cruel than the terrorism which resulted in self-mutilation.”
The Bolts account is cited in Bangladesh to this day. “The Daily Star” has also written that the thumbs were cut off in order to stop the production of muslin.
A conspiracy by British cloth manufacturers
British cloth manufacturers have been deemed the culprits based on different accounts. The late prominent British journalist, Ian Jake, described Bengal’s fine muslins as so cheap that Britain’s own cloth manufacturers conspired to cut off the fingers of Bengali weavers and break their looms in a column for “The Guardian.”
The American newspaper “The Forward” went further, stating that the British imperialists cut off the thumbs of Indians so they could not knit textiles. Interestingly, Congress stalwart Shashi Tharoor gave the story its most famous modern outing when he argued that Britain owes reparations to its former colonies in his famous speech at the Oxford Union on 28th May 2015.
He described the muslin weavers and said that Britain “came right in, smashed their thumbs, broke their looms,” imposed tariffs and duties on their cloth, and started taking raw materials from India. In an essay expanding on the speech that July, he wrote that Britain’s response was to cut off the thumbs of Bengali weavers, break their looms, and impose duties on Indian cloth, in a BBC piece.
He reiterated this in his 2016 book, “An Era of Darkness: The British Empire in India,” and highlighted, “Indian textiles were remarkably cheap – so much so that Britain’s cloth manufacturers, unable to compete, wanted them eliminated. The soldiers of the East India Company obliged, systematically smashing the looms of some Bengali weavers and, according to at least one contemporary account (as well as widespread, if unverifiable, belief), breaking their thumbs so they could not ply their craft.”
Rumina Sethi, who reviewed the book for “The Tribune,” summed it up as the textile industry being destroyed by the callous amputation of the thumbs of the Bengal weavers.
The weavers of Mahua Dabar
This ordeal does not end there and jumps to a sequel set in 1857 in the town of Mahua Dabar near Basti in present-day Uttar Pradesh. The place was dominated by weavers. According to the story, it was settled by twenty weaver families from Murshidabad and Nadia who had fled Bengal and were resettled there by the Nawab of Awadh.
They had to leave their homes in the early 19th century because the East India Company had cut off the hands of hundreds of weavers in Bengal to destroy the local weaving industry in favour of British textiles – and some accounts say that the thumbs of the weavers of Dacca were removed.
Many of the first-generation weavers had already lost their hands, but they taught the craft to their sons, and Mahua Dabar grew into a bustling handloom centre of about 5,000 people. Notably, the weavers, whose forefathers’ hands were chopped off by the British, took revenge during the revolt of 1857
“First, the people of Mahua Dabar had ruthlessly murdered Englishmen, cut off their heads and dismembered their bodies and thrown them into the Manorama River. The British rulers reacted with a fury that is unmatched in history,” a report in The Telegraph Online quoted historians
On 20th June 1857, the 12th Irregular Horse Cavalry surrounded the town, killed hundreds, and razed every home. The town was then wiped off the records by 3rd July, according to “Open Magazine.” The story was recovered through the fourteen-year search of a Mumbai tailor whose forefathers were weavers from Murshidabad who, he says, fled Bengal to escape the British atrocities on its weavers.
The platform, reporting on his search, wrote that archives at the National Library in Kolkata show that the British chopped off the thumbs and hands of master weavers in Bengal, and that many of them fled with their families to other parts of India.
Japan drops leaflets featuring Churchill
In 1944, Japan was engaged in a serious conflict with the British Empire. Meanwhile, its army came knocking on India’s eastern door, as Japanese planes dropped leaflets over Assam, which were based on British atrocities in India, including the weaving sector. The “National Army Museum” in London holds some of these leaflets to this day.
Interestingly, it describes one of them in the context of cases of weavers having their handlooms destroyed or even their fingers chopped off, while another displayed by “Homegrown” shows Winston Churchill personally cutting off the thumbs of Indian weavers.
Image via HomegrownA similar tale across different regions
It is not surprising that the story is not limited to India but has unfolded in different parts of the world. According to a legend connected to Ivan the Terrible of Russia, he blinded the architects of St. Basil’s Cathedral in Moscow after they completed it, so that they could never build anything so beautiful again. The architect is also described as an Italian in some versions of the story.
The same is talked about in two entries from American folklorist Stith Thompson in “Motif-Index of Folk-Literature,” who wrote, “King kills architect after completion of a great building, so that he may never again build one so great,” and “Artisan who has built palace blinded so that he cannot build another like it.”