Mildly interesting players are being non-tendered
· Yahoo Sports
The deadline for MLB teams to tender contracts to players who are on the 40 man roster but not currently under contract is 4 p.m. Central today. Players who are not tendered a contract by that time will become free agents.
Visit chickenroadslot.lat for more information.
This provides one of the nerdy kind of exciting times in the offseason — a meatier, more substantive version of the Rule 5 Draft. We get to speculate as to what arb-eligible players may be cut loose by teams that do not want to risk the player getting a salary in arbitration in excess of what the team thinks the player is worth. We get to see what contracts are announced today, thus learning which players were in danger of being non-tendered if they didn’t agree to a contract before the deadline.
And there will be a spate of players who will hit the free agent market and make us say, oh, hey, he’s a free agent, My Favorite Team should try to sign him. Usually that desire for Your Favorite Team to sign said player is dampened once you take a look at his recent performance level and/or injury history, but still, that bit of frisson when you see a name that once was associated with something of value being out there and available is something we can all enjoy in these noisome November nights.
Take, for instance, Nolan Gorman. He was the Cardinals’ first round pick in 2018, taken four picks after the Rangers selected Cole Winn. Keith Law actually mocked Gorman to the Rangers in one of his mock drafts that year.* He was a consensus top-100 prospect from 2019-22, and was a consensus top-35 prospect in 2022. In 2023 he put up an 805 OPS with 27 home runs. And he’s reportedly being non-tendered. The Rangers should jump all over him!
* In searching to see if I had done a draft preview of Gorman that year, I found this write-up I did in 2019 of someone named Jimmy Lewis. For the life of me, I have no memory of doing this write-up, or of this Jimmy Lewis guy ever existing.
Alas, he’s kind of been bad since then. He’s played second base and third base, neither of them well, and after slashing .204/.284/.385 in the 2024-25 seasons, Gorman ended up splitting 2026 between the majors and AAA, slashing .184/.272/.308 in the former and .182/.328/.430 in the latter. So yeah, you can see how he’s ended up in the late-November second wave of free agents.
Along those same lines, the Twins are reportedly non-tendering Bailey Ober and Trevor Larnach, each of whom were entering their final season of arbitration eligibility, and each of whom would seem to be in line for high-seven-figure 2027 salaries via the arbitration process. Needing to find the money for that $55 million deal they just gave Sonny Gray, the Twins are telling them to hit the bricks.
Larnach once good once, right? He was taken one pick after Gorman, as a matter of fact, in the 2018 draft. He was also a consensus top 100 prospect for a couple of seasons. He can help the Rangers, right?
Then you look deeper. He can’t hit lefties, and he has no value on defense or on the basepaths. He did put up a career beat .269/.352/.436 slash line in 433 plate appearances as a left fielder/DH, for a career high 1.4 bWAR. If your team is looking for Temu Joc Pederson, he might fit the bill.
Or what about Bailey Ober? He put up back-to-back 3.0 bWAR seasons as a member of the Twins’ rotation in 2023 and 2024. And he’s 6’9”, 260 lbs., and big pitchers like that are always fun. At a minimum, you’re not likely to be worried about someone rushing the mound on him.
Of course, since those two good seasons, his K rate has dropped, and he’s put up a 5.10 ERA and 4.47 ERA the past two seasons, with a 4.90 and 4.61 FIP. Even though he’s giant, his fastball velocity was in the bottom 1% in 2026, which is made even worse by the fact he’s a righthander, and thus can’t be described as “crafty.” In an impressive display of consistency, Ober was in the 11th percentile in 2026 in whiff rate, K rate and barrel rate. Disappointingly, he was in the 10th percentile in ground ball rate, and I’m now wishing he’d generated a couple more ground balls last year so that would also be in the 11th percentile.
Such is the bargain bin you are sifting through with the non-tender guys. Yeah, David Ortiz was once a non-tender, and occasionally you’ll see a Justin Turner success story — the Rangers got Marlon Byrd after he was non-tendered, and he turned in a couple of quality seasons for the Rangers. The Cubs non-tendered Kyle Schwarber just a few years ago, the Dodgers Cody Bellinger.
But those are the exceptions. Much more often, we talk ourselves into being fired up over the likes of David Dahl, only to see him put up a 569 OPS for one of the worst Rangers teams ever, and ultimately get released because the likes of Jason Martin and DJ Peters were more worthy options.